The United Methodist Church of Sayville was established in 1833 as a stop on the East Long Island circuit. Meetings were held in local homes until 1845, when the church was erected along Jericho Tpke on property donated by the Oakley family. Methodist classes held regular meetings on the fourth Friday of each month at Jonas Newton's home in what is now Oakdale. The North Shore United Methodist Church was founded in 1970 with twenty founding members of the First United Methodist Church of Port Jefferson, New York.
There weren't any United Methodist churches in Comac until after 1918, since Brindley Field, in Comac, was brought in for its own use during the First World War, and it became available for homes, stores, and the Church. In 1810, Comac became part of the Suffolk County Circuit along with Happlauge and Sag Harbor, with preachers Henry Redstone and Coles Carpenter. Sayville United Methodist Church is an active, community-oriented church with a healthy and diverse congregation of many ages and stages of faith. The church was resurrected in 1995 with many prayers, as the current building was erected on the site of the first church.
However, the historic building that we now call our Chapel from 1789 has the distinction of being the oldest Methodist church in continuous use in New York, where people still worship in the original building, with few modifications. The purpose of the West Hills United Methodist Church is to be a living church that accepts the message of Jesus that God loves and accepts all people. In 1939, in preparation for the 150th anniversary, the building was painted, the landscape of the church grounds was improved, and a circular road was built with Belgian blocks and a border, which continued along the sidewalk as a WPA project. Visiting a United Methodist church in Suffolk County NY can be an exciting experience for those looking to explore their faith or deepen their understanding of Methodism. At these churches you can expect to experience vibrant worship services that are alive with singing and prayer.
Last year, Bayport United Methodist Church welcomed a new pastor who has worked hard to maintain and increase the church's connections to the community. Methodism in Winne-Comac began in 1783, when a society was formed after a sermon preached by John Phillips, a local Methodist preacher and tailor in the British Army during the War of Independence. No matter which United Methodist church you visit in Suffolk County NY, you can expect to find a welcoming atmosphere where all are accepted and encouraged to grow in their faith. Whether you are looking for a place to worship or just want to learn more about Methodism, there is something for everyone at these churches.